Final reflections on the USA

I thought a good way of signing off from my time in Boston was to share my impressions of the differences between the UK and USA, in business and some other stuff too! I'll start with things the US might learn from the UK - check out my next blog for the other way round!

  1. Flatten the cube!
    High walls. Lots of offices. Silence. These are all things that were alien to me before my arrival in the USA, and I hope they were but temporary experiences. It might be traditional, but to me these things stifle creativity, keep people thinking in their own silos, and get in the way of the informal network building that I believe is essential to success.
  2. Another MBA? Really?
    This might sound counter-intuitive from someone who has just experienced, I would say, some of the best of the US business school experience, but I find it crazy the number of my colleagues who had MBA's, and the way they are perceived. For me, the best of business school was the privilege of having some time to indulge one's curiosity, and have the space and time to think through the issues that I was interested in. I didn't see this curiosity in many of my colleagues, and an MBA seemed to be seen by many as a box ticking exercise to proceed on the corporate treadmill. This was never how I perceived the Babson experience, ably abetted by the curiosity shown by all the Fellows.
  3. Embracing the weird
    I feel on less certain ground here, but my perception of large company culture in the USA (I've seen enough of the entrepreneurial scene to know this isn't true there) is that there is less room for the eccentrics. I've known plenty of peope in my experience who are completely invaluable, and yet also undoubtedly strange! From the engineer who spends far too much time in a darkened room, to the product manager whose chosen approach is to say exactly what she thinks of everyone to their face, these characters have enriched my working life, as well as being pivotal members of the organization. Maybe too many MBA's in America designing the corporate culture?

What did everyone else see that the US could learn from how things are done in the UK? And what do you think of my suggestions?

 

Ian


Posted 03-Aug-2009 14:23 by Ian Webster
Filed under: , ,

Comments

Ian Stevenson wrote re: Final reflections on the USA
on 04-Aug-2009 9:34

Hi Ian,

I sympathise with the point about cubicles - Sun was all offices and it could get pretty quie when we were all in our little hutches.  Mine was windowless which is never that great for the ambience...

Just across the corridor from me the printer sat in a lovely open plan area with three windows.  Not a day went by when I didn't wish I could swap with it.

Your observations on MBAs are interesting. I have the same sense that they are often perceived as a handle turning exercise.  I never got that sense quite so much in the UK. A view of things to come here perhaps?  Or is the MBA culture here different in some way?

I wonder what will take it's place as an unreservedly  prestigious qualification, other than the Saltire Fellowship of course.  

Mubbasher Khanzada wrote re: Final reflections on the USA
on 11-Aug-2009 22:06

Things US can learn from UK:

Subtlety (especially in TV ads)!

And there is a thing called blue tac, using which means we don't have to puncture the walls (and get sore thumbs trying to push pins in cement)

And displaying prices in shops INCLUSIVE of taxes.

And smaller cars

Also, the receiving party on mobile shouldn't have to pay, and if I haven't used it, the money I put in it should still be there after the end of the month!!!!!!

Mubbasher.

Add a Comment

(required)  
(optional)
(required)  
Remember Me?